Dating Red Flags
Dating would be considerably easier if red flags actually looked like red flags.
Unfortunately, they often look rather different in the beginning.
They can look like intense interest.
Protectiveness.
Chemistry.
Wanting to spend every minute together.
A person telling you they have “never felt this way before.”
Someone who wants to know where you are because they “worry about you.”
Someone who is jealous because they “care so much.”
Or someone who tells you their previous five partners were all completely unhinged and they were simply the innocent victim of astonishingly bad luck.
The early stages of dating are particularly tricky because attraction changes the way we process information. When we like someone, we naturally pay greater attention to evidence that supports our positive impression of them and may explain away information that does not.
We also don’t yet have much data.
Anyone can behave beautifully for three dates.
What tells you far more about somebody is what happens when:
- you disagree with them;
- you say no;
- you are unavailable;
- they don’t get what they want;
- you spend time with other people;
- you express a different opinion;
- you ask them to take responsibility;
- or you set a boundary.
And this is where red flags become much easier to see.
What Does the Research Say About Relationship Red Flags?
Relationship warning signs aren’t simply a social-media invention.
Researchers developing the Relationship Red Flags Scale identified five broad groups of behaviours associated with warning signs of dating violence:
Monitoring behaviours, controlling behaviours, demeaning behaviours, threatening or aggressive behaviours, and jealous or possessive behaviours.
That doesn’t mean that every insecure moment or unfortunate comment predicts an abusive relationship.
Human beings are imperfect.
We become defensive. We say stupid things. We get jealous. We communicate badly.
The better questions are:
Is this becoming a pattern?
What happens when I challenge it?
Does the person take responsibility?
Do they respect my autonomy?
Am I gradually becoming smaller in order to keep the relationship peaceful?
Relationship researchers John and Julie Gottman’s work is useful here too.
Gottman identified four particularly destructive communication patterns: criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling.
Contempt — including ridicule, mockery, sneering, superiority and belittling — is particularly concerning.
Modern dating also brings another category into the picture: digital control.
Research describes digital dating abuse as using technology to monitor, pressure, threaten, harass or control a partner. This can include repeatedly checking someone’s whereabouts, demanding access to their phone, monitoring social media, sexual pressure through messaging or expecting constant digital availability.
So how good is your own red-flag radar?
Let’s find out.
The Dating Red Flag Quiz
For each situation, choose the response you think best identifies what is happening.
Keep track of how many you get right.
Some are deliberately more difficult than others.
Question 1: The Constant Texter
You’ve been on two dates.
The following morning they text you.
You don’t reply because you’re working.
Within one hour:
“Everything okay?”
Soon after:
“Have I done something?”
Then:
“I can see you’ve been online.”
What is the most important thing to notice?
A. They’re clearly very attracted to you.
B. They probably just have an anxious attachment style, so there’s nothing to worry about.
C. Their anxiety is already creating pressure for you to account for your availability.
D. You’re being rude by not replying.
Answer: C
Being keen isn’t the red flag.
Expecting access to you — and monitoring whether you’ve been online — potentially is.
Attachment anxiety is associated with heightened cognitive and behavioural jealousy, particularly where trust is low. Research has also linked attachment anxiety with monitoring and snooping behaviours.
An explanation for behaviour isn’t the same as permission for it.
Someone can feel anxious and still respect your boundaries.
Question 2: “I’ve Never Felt Like This Before”
You’ve known someone for nine days.
They tell you:
“You’re different from anyone I’ve ever met. I genuinely think you could be the one.”
Red flag?
A. Definitely. Anyone who falls quickly is dangerous.
B. Not necessarily. The important issue is what comes with the intensity.
C. No. It means you’re compatible.
D. Only if they buy you presents.
Answer: B
Rapid emotional intensity isn’t automatically unhealthy.
Some people genuinely become excited quickly.
The useful question is whether intensity is accompanied by pressure.
For example:
“If you felt what I felt, you’d delete the dating apps.”
“Why do you still need to see your friends when we have each other?”
“I know it’s soon, but we should move in together.”
Affection allows you to move at your own pace.
Control tries to accelerate intimacy so that your normal boundaries disappear.
Question 3: Everyone They Dated Was “Crazy”
Your date describes four previous relationships.
Apparently one ex was narcissistic, another was “psycho”, another cheated because she was “damaged”, and another became “obsessed.”
What is the potential red flag?
A. Having several unsuccessful relationships.
B. Talking about an ex.
C. A complete absence of self-reflection about their own role in repeated relationship difficulties.
D. Using the word narcissist.
Answer: C
Plenty of people genuinely have had painful or abusive relationships.
The red flag isn’t someone’s difficult history.
It is chronic externalisation of responsibility.
Emotionally mature people can usually say something like:
“They behaved badly, but there are things I would do differently now too.”
Someone who consistently portrays themselves as completely blameless deserves a little more observation.
Gottman’s research highlights defensiveness and refusal to accept responsibility as particularly damaging communication patterns when they become habitual.
Question 4: The Password Test
You’ve been dating for approximately six weeks.
They say:
“If we’re serious, we shouldn’t have secrets. Give me your phone password. You can have mine.”
What is the healthiest response?
A. Exchange passwords because trust requires transparency.
B. Refuse immediately because people in relationships should never know each other’s passwords.
C. Recognise that mutual consent is possible, but demanding digital access as proof of love is concerning.
D. Give them the password unless you’ve got something to hide.
Answer: C
Couples can voluntarily share passwords.
The issue is coercion.
Privacy and secrecy are not the same thing.
Digital dating-abuse research specifically identifies technological monitoring and control as concerning behaviours.
Question 5: The Jealous Compliment
Someone says:
“I hate it when other people look at you. You’re too attractive. I don’t want anyone else getting ideas.”
Romantic or red flag?
A. Romantic.
B. Definitely abusive.
C. Potentially either — watch what behaviour follows the feeling.
D. Proof of insecure attachment.
Answer: C
Jealousy is an emotion.
People don’t become controlling simply because they occasionally experience it.
The behavioural response matters.
Compare:
“I felt strangely jealous tonight. I know that’s mine to deal with.”
with:
“I don’t want you wearing that when I’m not there.”
The first takes responsibility for an emotion.
The second begins controlling another person’s behaviour.
Research consistently associates attachment insecurity, particularly attachment anxiety, with higher levels of jealousy — but feeling jealous is very different from using jealousy to justify surveillance or control.
Question 6: The Small Insult
Your date says:
“You’re actually really intelligent. I wouldn’t have guessed that when I first met you.”
You laugh awkwardly.
They reply:
“Relax. Can’t you take a joke?”
What’s potentially concerning?
A. Nothing. It’s teasing.
B. The insult itself is proof they’re abusive.
C. The combination of a put-down followed by dismissing your reaction.
D. Your lack of humour.
Answer: C
One clumsy joke doesn’t define somebody.
But repeated belittling followed by:
“You’re too sensitive.”
“I was only joking.”
or
“You take everything personally”
deserves attention.
Women’s Aid includes mocking, insulting, humiliating and repeatedly putting someone down among emotionally abusive and coercive behaviours.
Gottman’s concept of contempt is relevant here too: mockery, ridicule, superiority and sneering can become deeply damaging relationship patterns.
Question 7: You Cancel a Date
You’re exhausted and cancel dinner.
Which response is healthiest?
A. “Fine.”
Then they disappear for three days.
B. “Clearly I’m more interested in this than you are.”
C. “That’s disappointing, but I understand. Are you free another evening?”
D. “If you cared, you’d make the effort.”
Answer: C
This question tests something enormously important:
How does somebody respond when they don’t get what they want?
Disappointment is normal.
Punishment, guilt, emotional withdrawal or retaliation is different.
Question 8: Location Sharing
Your new partner suggests permanently sharing your phone locations.
They say:
“It’s safer, and couples do it nowadays.”
What should determine whether this is healthy?
A. Whether both people freely want it and either can withdraw consent without consequences.
B. Whether you’re officially boyfriend and girlfriend.
C. Whether they share theirs too.
D. Whether you’ve been dating longer than three months.
Answer: A
Technology itself isn’t the problem.
Control is.
Monitoring where someone goes, whom they speak to or what they do online is recognised within research on digital dating abuse.
Consent should remain reversible.
Question 9: The Friend Problem
Your partner says:
“I don’t trust your friend Alex. They’re obviously attracted to you.”
What makes this most concerning?
A. Feeling jealous.
B. Telling you about the jealousy.
C. Insisting that you stop seeing Alex.
D. Disliking one of your friends.
Answer: C
A healthy partner may occasionally dislike one of your friends.
The red flag is when discomfort becomes control over your social world.
Isolation from friends and family is an important warning sign of coercive control.
And isolation doesn’t always sound threatening.
Sometimes it sounds like:
“They’re bad for you.”
“Your family doesn’t respect our relationship.”
“We always argue after you see them.”
“I’d rather it was just us tonight.”
Repeated often enough, your world becomes smaller.
Question 10: The Boundary Test
You’ve said you don’t want sex tonight.
Which response should concern you most?
A. “Okay. Fancy watching a film?”
B. “Okay — can I ask if something’s wrong?”
C. “Of course.”
They seem disappointed but leave it there.
D. “Seriously? We’ve been seeing each other for a month. What exactly are you waiting for?”
Answer: D
Consent isn’t something someone earns through dates, affection or time invested.
Sexual pressure, harassment and intimidation are recognised forms of abuse.
A useful dating rule is:
Watch what happens after you say no.
It reveals a remarkable amount about a person’s respect for your autonomy.
Question 11: They Are Rude to Everyone Except You
Your date is charming with you but snaps at the waiter, insults another driver and speaks contemptuously about colleagues.
Should you care?
A. No. What matters is how they treat you.
B. Yes. How people treat those from whom they need nothing can reveal something about their interpersonal style.
C. Only if the waiter complains.
D. Only if they insult you too.
Answer: B
Early dating behaviour is partly impression management.
Most of us present our best selves.
Observing how somebody responds to frustration, inconvenience, service staff, family members and strangers provides useful information about empathy, entitlement and emotional regulation.
Charm directed exclusively at the person someone wishes to impress isn’t necessarily evidence of kindness.
Question 12: The Argument
You tell someone that something they said upset you.
Which reply is the best green flag?
A. “You’re twisting what I said.”
B. “Well, you upset me last week.”
C. “I didn’t mean it that way, but I can understand why it hurt. I’m sorry.”
D. “I guess I’m just a terrible person then.”
Answer: C
Look for the ability to repair.
Emotionally healthy people aren’t people who never cause hurt.
They are people who can listen, reflect, apologise and adjust.
Gottman’s relationship research places considerable importance on how couples handle conflict, including responsibility-taking and repair attempts.
Question 13: The Social Media Interrogation
Someone you’re dating asks:
“Who is that person who liked your photo?”
You tell them it’s an old colleague.
Later they ask:
“Why did you like their picture back?”
What should you watch for?
A. Any question about social media.
B. Whether curiosity turns into repeated monitoring, accusations or demands.
C. Whether they also follow the colleague.
D. Whether the colleague is attractive.
Answer: B
Social media creates endless ambiguous information for anxious minds to interpret.
Research has found links between attachment anxiety and online jealousy, while wider digital-dating-abuse research distinguishes ordinary curiosity from repeated monitoring and control.
Question 14: The Sudden Sulk
You decide to spend Saturday with your friends instead of the person you’ve recently started seeing.
They don’t forbid you from going.
Instead they become cold, withdrawn and miserable.
When you ask what’s wrong they say:
“Nothing. Have fun.”
Then barely communicate until Sunday evening.
Potential red flag?
A. No, because they didn’t actually stop you going.
B. Possibly — particularly if emotional withdrawal repeatedly functions as punishment when you exercise independence.
C. Yes. People should never be disappointed.
D. No. Silent treatment is always healthy emotional regulation.
Answer: B
Behaviour doesn’t have to include an explicit instruction to become controlling.
If independence repeatedly results in punishment, guilt, sulking or withdrawal, you may eventually begin changing your behaviour simply to prevent their reaction.
Women’s Aid specifically identifies withholding communication, affection or approval as punishment as a potentially abusive behaviour.
Question 15: “You’re Too Sensitive”
Every disagreement ends in some version of:
“That didn’t happen.”
“You’ve remembered it wrong.”
“You’re imagining things.”
“You’re too emotional.”
What’s the biggest concern?
A. They have a different memory.
B. Any disagreement about past events.
C. A repeated pattern that causes you to distrust your own perception.
D. They have better emotional regulation.
Answer: C
People genuinely remember events differently.
That alone isn’t gaslighting.
Gaslighting involves a pattern of manipulation that causes someone to doubt their perception or reality.
Women’s Aid describes this as a recognised form of emotional abuse.
Be particularly alert if you find yourself increasingly thinking:
“Maybe I’m imagining everything.”
“Maybe I really am too sensitive.”
“Maybe everything is my fault.”
Question 16: The Most Important Question
Which of these is arguably one of the most useful things to observe during early dating?
A. How frequently someone texts you.
B. How impressive their career is.
C. How strongly they say they feel about you.
D. How they respond to your boundaries, independence, disagreement and the word “no.”
Answer: D
This is the big one.
Anybody can be charming when everything is going their way.
Character tends to become more visible when it isn’t.
How Did You Score?
Give yourself one point for each correct answer.
14–16: Your Red-Flag Radar Is Sharp
You’re pretty good at separating intensity from intimacy and jealousy from control.
Most importantly, you appear to understand that red flags are often about patterns and responses to boundaries, rather than isolated behaviours.
Don’t abandon that knowledge simply because someone is extremely attractive.
Your prefrontal cortex would like a word.
10–13: Pretty Good — But Chemistry May Occasionally Distract You
You’re noticing the obvious warning signs but may occasionally give questionable behaviour an overly generous explanation.
Remember:
Understanding why somebody behaves a certain way doesn’t mean you have to tolerate the behaviour.
“They’ve been hurt before.”
“They’re insecure.”
“Their ex cheated.”
“They have an anxious attachment style.”
All may be completely true.
None automatically justifies control.
6–9: You May Be Explaining Away More Than You Realise
You may have a tendency to focus heavily on someone’s intentions rather than the impact of their behaviour.
Try replacing:
“But they only do it because they care.”
with:
“What effect does this behaviour have on my freedom, confidence and wellbeing?”
Intent matters.
Impact matters too.
0–5: Time to Upgrade Your Red-Flag Detector
Don’t panic.
Red-flag awareness is a skill.
Many unhealthy behaviours have been romanticised for decades.
Jealousy has been sold as passion.
Possessiveness as devotion.
Constant contact as intimacy.
Emotional volatility as chemistry.
And obsession as proof that someone has finally met “the one.”
Learning to recognise the difference can fundamentally change whom we choose.
The Difference Between a Red Flag and a Flawed Human Being
There is a danger with discussions about relationship red flags.
If we’re not careful, everyone becomes a red flag.
Someone texts twice?
Red flag.
Someone feels jealous?
Red flag.
Someone doesn’t reply quickly?
Avoidant narcissist!
Someone likes pineapple on pizza?
Frankly suspicious, but still not clinically significant.
Real relationships involve misunderstandings, insecurity, occasionally terrible communication and moments we wish we could replay differently.
What matters much more is pattern, intensity, flexibility and accountability.
Ask yourself:
Can we talk about this?
Can they hear feedback without attacking me?
Can they apologise?
Does their behaviour change?
Can I disagree without being punished?
Can I maintain friendships and interests outside the relationship?
Can I say no?
Can they tolerate uncertainty without controlling me?
Do I feel increasingly free to be myself — or increasingly careful?
That final question can be surprisingly powerful.
Healthy relationships generally allow your world to remain the same size or become larger.
Unhealthy ones often shrink it gradually.
You stop wearing certain clothes.
Stop mentioning certain friends.
Stop disagreeing.
Stop going out.
Start responding instantly.
Start explaining where you are.
Start editing your personality.
Not necessarily because anyone explicitly ordered you to.
But because it became easier than dealing with the consequences.
Red Flags Often Begin as Small Boundary Tests
This is why early dating matters.
People are constantly learning how a new relationship works.
If someone makes a jealous comment and you immediately reassure them for an hour, they learn something.
If they demand your location and you provide it, they learn something.
If they insult you and you laugh because you don’t want to seem oversensitive, they learn something.
But you are learning too.
You’re learning:
“It’s easier not to challenge this.”
This doesn’t mean every inappropriate comment is a calculated manipulation.
Often it isn’t.
The important information comes next:
What happens when you establish the boundary?
Suppose somebody checks your phone.
You say:
“Please don’t do that. I value my privacy.”
Compare these two responses.
“You’re right. Sorry. I felt insecure, but I shouldn’t have done that.”
versus:
“Why are you so defensive? What are you hiding?”
Same original behaviour.
Very different psychological information.
Don’t Confuse Intensity With Intimacy
One of the easiest mistakes in early dating is assuming strong emotion equals strong connection.
It doesn’t.
Real intimacy takes information.
You have to discover who somebody is.
How do they behave when they’re tired?
Frustrated?
Jealous?
Rejected?
Embarrassed?
Wrong?
Disappointed?
How do they speak about vulnerable people?
What happens when you succeed?
What happens when you need support?
Can they tolerate your independence?
Can they accommodate needs that aren’t identical to theirs?
You cannot genuinely know these things after three magical dinners and seventy-four WhatsApp messages.
You may have chemistry.
You may have possibility.
You don’t yet have evidence.
There’s nothing cynical about remembering that.
One Red Flag Doesn’t Always Mean Run — But Some Deserve Immediate Attention
Context matters for many relationship behaviours.
But certain behaviours should always be taken seriously, particularly:
- threats;
- intimidation;
- sexual coercion;
- stalking;
- physical aggression;
- destruction of property;
- threats to harm you, themselves, children or animals in order to control you;
- significant isolation;
- financial control;
- persistent surveillance;
- repeated humiliation or degradation.
Women’s Aid describes many of these behaviours within patterns of domestic abuse and coercive control.
If fear enters the relationship, the question is no longer:
“Is this person a red flag?”
The question becomes:
“Am I safe?”
Perhaps We Should Look for Green Flags Too
Dating shouldn’t become an FBI investigation where we spend dinner quietly documenting evidence.
Look for what is healthy as well.
Green flags include someone who:
respects a no;
doesn’t rush you;
can apologise;
has relationships outside the romantic relationship;
allows you to have yours;
doesn’t require constant reassurance;
can disagree respectfully;
is curious about your perspective;
doesn’t humiliate people;
accepts responsibility;
doesn’t need access to your phone;
doesn’t punish independence;
can handle disappointment;
supports your interests;
and leaves you feeling more like yourself rather than less.
Perhaps the greatest green flag is this:
You don’t have to abandon yourself to keep the relationship.
Final Thought
When we’re attracted to someone, most of us ask:
“Do they like me?”
A better question is:
“Do I like who I become around them?”
Do you feel relaxed?
Respected?
Interesting?
Independent?
Able to speak?
Able to disagree?
Able to maintain the rest of your life?
Or have you started performing emotional gymnastics in order to keep somebody happy?
Dating isn’t only about finding someone who chooses you.
It’s about gathering enough information to decide whether you should choose them.
And sometimes the smallest red flag isn’t an instruction to leave immediately.
It’s simply an invitation to stop, pay attention and gather more data.
Your heart is allowed to be excited.
Just don’t send your observational skills on annual leave while it happens.
Sources and further reading
This quiz draws particularly on research into relationship warning signs, jealousy, attachment, digital dating abuse, coercive control and destructive communication patterns. Research on the Relationship Red Flags Scale identified monitoring, controlling, demeaning, threatening/aggressive and jealous/possessive behaviours as key warning-sign domains.
Research has also linked distrust and attachment anxiety with behavioural jealousy and intrusive monitoring, while studies of digital dating abuse identify surveillance, coercion and technological control as important relationship concerns.
The Gottman Institute’s relationship research describes criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling as particularly destructive communication patterns, while Women’s Aid provides detailed guidance on emotional abuse, isolation, monitoring and coercive control.
This article is for education and self-reflection rather than diagnosis. A quiz cannot determine whether somebody is abusive, has a personality disorder or whether a relationship is safe. Patterns, context, severity and your individual circumstances matter.


